Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

[Blknight3]

We went to see this last night, and we were at complete opposites on our opinions on this one. She gave it a 3 out of 10. I gave it a 7.

It was a lot lighter than the previous, with a lot more humor which was good. However when it came to following the book they butchered it. They took out some pertinent facts and filled it with stiff that was never in the bookto begin with... that had no bearing on the storyline.

I think they could have stuck more to the book and left out the made up and not added evena minute to the timeline. This one deviates far more than any of the other movies did.

Based on a movie only I give it a B. If I base it on the books then I give it a C-